What Is a Broker Fee and Why Do Insurance Brokers Charge Them?

Let’s address the elephant in the room. You’ve looked at a broker’s invoice and seen a line item for “broker fee” on top of the premium. And you’ve wondered: if the insurer already pays the broker commission, why am I also paying a fee?

It’s a fair question. And at Tank Insurance, we’d rather give you the honest answer than dodge it.

What is a broker fee?

A broker fee is a charge from your insurance broker for the service they provide. It covers the work involved in:

• Understanding your business and its risks
• Reviewing your current insurance arrangements
• Shopping the market across multiple insurers
• Comparing quotes on price, cover, and insurer quality
• Recommending the right policy and explaining the differences
• Arranging the policy and issuing documents
• Managing mid-term changes (additions, deletions, endorsements)
• Handling claims when something goes wrong
• Reviewing your insurance at each renewal

The fee is separate from the insurance premium (which goes to the insurer) and separate from commission (which the insurer pays the broker from the premium).

How does it differ from commission?

This is the part most people find confusing. Here’s the breakdown:

	Commission	Broker Fee
Paid by	The insurer (from your premium)	You (on top of the premium)
Visible to you	Built into the premium - you don’t see it separately	Shown as a line item on your invoice
Amount	Generally around 10-20% of the premium	Varies - can be a flat dollar amount or percentage
Who sets it	The insurer (as part of their distribution cost)	The broker

Commission has always been part of how insurance works. When you buy direct from an insurer, the insurer keeps the full premium. When you buy through a broker, the insurer pays the broker a commission from that premium. In most cases, the insurer’s direct price and the broker’s price are often similar - the commission replaces the insurer’s own distribution costs.

The broker fee is additional. Not every broker charges one, and those who do charge different amounts. Your broker’s Financial Services Guide (FSG) will tell you whether they may charge a fee and how it’s calculated. The actual amount is disclosed when you receive your quote or invoice.

Why do brokers charge a fee on top of commission?

The honest answer: commission alone often doesn’t cover the cost of the service a broker provides, particularly for smaller policies.

Here’s the maths. A $2,000 annual business insurance premium might generate $300-$400 in commission. That commission needs to cover:

• The initial consultation and needs analysis
• Market research and quoting across multiple insurers
• Policy comparison and recommendation
• Documentation and policy issuance
• Ongoing service throughout the year
• Claims management when something goes wrong
• The annual renewal review

For a $300-$400 commission to cover all of that, the broker would need to spend very little time on your account - which means less thorough service.

A broker fee supplements the commission to ensure the broker can provide a proper service. It’s the difference between a quick online quote with no advice and a thorough, personalised insurance review with ongoing support.

What do you actually get for your broker fee?

Here’s what a good broker provides that a direct insurer or comparison site doesn’t:

Market access

A broker shops your insurance to multiple insurers - often 5-15+ depending on the risk. A direct insurer only offers their own products. A comparison site typically shows 3-4 options. More options means a better chance of finding the right cover at the best price.

Cover quality review

A broker doesn’t just compare prices. They compare policy wordings - the exclusions, sub-limits, conditions, and definitions that determine whether a claim gets paid. The cheapest policy isn’t always the best one.

We’ve written about this in our guide on cheap insurance exclusions that void claims.

Claims advocacy

This is where a broker’s value becomes most obvious. When you need to make a claim, your broker:

• Helps you frame the claim correctly (how you describe the event matters)
• Lodges the claim with the right documentation
• Follows up with the insurer on your behalf
• Advocates for you if the claim is disputed or underpaid
• Manages the process so you can focus on your business

We outlined this process in our claims guide. Having someone in your corner during a claim is worth far more than the annual fee.

Annual review

At every renewal, a broker reviews your insurance against your current business situation. Has your revenue changed? Have you added employees? Are your sums insured still adequate? Do you need new covers? This proactive review catches gaps before they become problems.

Specialist knowledge

For businesses with complex or hard-to-place risks - engineering firms, hospitality, strata, NFPs - a broker brings specialist knowledge that direct channels simply don’t have.

The “free” comparison site model

Some people prefer comparison sites because there’s no visible broker fee. But the comparison site isn’t free - it’s funded by commission and referral fees from the insurers on the platform.

The trade-off:

• Limited options - comparison sites typically show a small number of insurers, not the full market
• No advice - the site compares on price, not on cover quality or suitability
• No claims support - if you need to claim, you deal with the insurer directly
• No annual review - your policy auto-renews without anyone checking whether it’s still right
• No advocacy - if a claim is disputed, there’s no one in your corner

For simple, low-risk insurance (basic car insurance, straightforward contents), a comparison site can work fine. For business insurance where the policy wording matters and claims support is critical, a broker provides genuine value.

Is the fee worth it?

We’re obviously biased. But here’s our honest view: for most businesses, yes.

The premium savings from shopping the full market can often offset the broker fee. And the claims advocacy, cover quality review, and annual reassessment provide value that’s hard to put a dollar figure on - until you need it.

The exception might be a sole trader with a single, simple policy and very low risk. In that case, a direct insurer may be sufficient. But even then, the first time you need to make a claim and you’re dealing with the insurer alone, you may wish you had a broker.

For more on why businesses use brokers, see our experienced broker page.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an insurance broker fee?

A charge from your broker for arranging and managing your insurance. It’s separate from the premium (which goes to the insurer) and commission (which the insurer pays the broker). It must be disclosed before you agree to the service.

What is the difference between a broker fee and commission?

Commission is paid by the insurer to the broker from your premium. A broker fee is charged directly to you for the broker’s service. Some brokers charge only commission, some only a fee, some both.

Is a broker fee tax deductible?

Generally, yes. Broker fees for business insurance are typically deductible as a business expense - but check with your accountant for your specific situation.

Is it worth paying a broker fee for insurance?

For most businesses, yes. Market access, cover quality review, claims advocacy, and annual reviews typically provide value that exceeds the fee - especially when you need to claim.

Want to see what a broker can do for your business?

If you’re currently buying insurance direct and wondering whether a broker would get you a better deal, there’s an easy way to find out. Get a comparison from Tank Insurance. We’ll show you what the full market offers and you can decide whether the difference is worth it.

Call us on 02 9000 1155 or email [email protected].

---

This is general information only and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. You should consider whether the information is appropriate for you and read the relevant Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) before making any decisions about insurance products.